In an era of fake news and questionable political advisers, the Popish plot is a reminder that the political intrigues and scandals of the past could be equally as strange as those of today and that they could have deadly consequences. An invented plot about a Catholic conspiracy to kill Charles II in 1678 led to numerous trials, executions and the exclusion of Catholics from both Houses of Parliament for 150 years. In terms of the hysteria caused and the number of people killed, the Popish plot can be compared to the Salem witch trails in America. Yet what is remarkable about the whole affair is that leading politicians and Parliament encouraged the investigations which went on for three years.
To understand how an event like this could have taken place, it is worth remembering the extent of anti-Catholicism in the 17th century. Following Elizabeth I’s religious settlement, Catholics experienced continued persecution and Jesuits were executed as traitors. The memory of the Gunpowder plot of 1605 continued to fuel fears of a Catholic attempt to assassinate the King and take over the country. Charles I and Archbishop Laud’s religious policy was seen as reintroducing aspects of Catholicism into the Church of England and was a key factor in the outbreak of the British Civil Wars. Anti-Catholic feeling was again stirred by the Great Plague and Great Fire of London, for which Catholics were often blamed. The Test Act of 1673 ensured that anyone taking public office had to deny the Catholic belief in transubstantiation and receive communion in the Church of England.
The two men behind the invented plot, Titus Oates and Israel Tonge, were certainly an odd pair. Titus Oates’ father was the vicar of Hastings in Kent and Oates himself spent some time at Cambridge but did not graduate. He was eventually ordained after lying about having a degree and later served as a chaplain on board HMS Adventure. Israel Tonge was almost 30 years older than Oates, had a degree from Oxford and had even taught at the short-lived Durham College during the Commonwealth. After this he became a chaplain at the British garrison at Dunkirk and then vicar of St Mary Staining in London which was burnt down in the Great Fire. Tonge and Oates first met in 1677 and they agreed to write a series of anti-Catholic pamphlets. Strangely, Oates supposedly became a Roman Catholic at this time and was admitted to the English College at Valladolid in Spain. After being expelled he was admitted to the Jesuit College of St Omer in France and again was expelled in June 1678. Oates would later claim that he had not actually converted and his time abroad was just a way to learn more about the Jesuits from the inside.
The real turning point in how the plot was viewed came on 12 October when Godfrey disappeared and was then found dead five days later. The presumed murder sent shockwaves through the court and the House of Lords requested that all Catholics be sent at least 20 miles outside of London. Charles called Parliament on 21 October and Oates and Tonge again gave accounts of the supposed plot. This time Oates accused five members of the House of Lords and Parliament agreed to have them arrested. There was a political dimension to this as the arrest of the Lords was led by the Earl of Shaftesbury, leader of the opposition to Danby. The impeachment and trials of the “five popish Lords” as they became known dragged on over the next two years (see below). In the meantime the public became increasingly on edge and the rest of the year became known as ‘Godfrey’s autumn’. One of the ways in which Godfrey was remembered as a Protestant ‘martyr’ was the production of the ‘Godfrey dagger’ (this has been featured in a previous blog on the Library’s artefacts) . Thousands of these were sold in London and the Library has a particularly fine example, with engraving on the blade and a silver hilt.
The next development in the plot came on 21 December with the arrest of Miles Prance, who was a Catholic servant of the Queen. Oates had already accused Catherine of treason but her loyalty to the King and support from the House of Lords ensured her safety. After several confessions and recantations, Prance eventually accused three workmen of Godfrey’s murder and implicated Thomas Godden, the Queen’s chaplain. With no evidence the three workmen were sentenced to death in February 1679 and Godden fled for France. Public uncertainty and anger continued though as shown in the broadside, England’s grand memorial... This shows Godfrey in the centre as “the Kingdom’s martyr” and the text recounts the supposed Jesuit involvement in the Great Fire and Oates and Tonge’s ‘revealing’ of the plot. The supposed actions of the murderers of Godfrey are depicted – the people accused by Prance – two priests called Kelly and Fitzgerald who ‘disappeared’ or may not have existed at all, and the workmen Robert Green, Henry Berry and Lawrence Hill.
Throughout 1679 and 1680 the trials of the five Catholic lords were continually delayed and rearranged. Eventually, William Howard, Viscount Stafford (whose great-grandfather had been executed and whose grandfather died imprisoned in the Tower during Elizabeth I’s reign) was the only one put on trial and was executed in December 1680. The others were imprisoned for several years with Baron William Petre dying in January 1684. The last victim of the plot was Oliver Plunkett, the Catholic Archbishop of Armagh. Originally arrested in Ireland in December 1679, the Earl of Shaftesbury had Plunkett brought to London to be tried at Westminster Hall. Like many others, although it was clear that he had never been involved in any threats to the King, he was found guilty. The deaths of such high profile figures as Stafford and Plunkett were the final straw for the increasingly discredited plot. Plunkett was to be the last Roman Catholic priest executed for his religion in England.
What of Oates himself? As the plot gained ground in 1678 Oates was treated as a hero, he received a grace-and-favour house in Whitehall with £1,200 a year. He wrote A true narrative of the horrid plot and conspiracy of the popish party… (1679) [KA448 2.01], unlike most political pamphlets of the day, this was printed in folio size. After Plunkett’s death, opinion turned against Oates and he was told to leave his apartment and was then arrested for sedition. He was imprisoned for the rest of Charles II’s reign and when James II became King he was convicted for perjury and repeatedly whipped and pilloried. With the revolution of 1689 and accession of the Protestant William III, Oates was let out of prison and received a government pension, eventually dying in 1705. By this time the Act of Settlement in 1701 had made it a legal requirement that the monarch must be Protestant. Oates’ Popish plot was not only the final deadly act of officially sanctioned anti-Catholicism in England, it also quickened the development of modern two-party politics.
The accidental Anglican
Anglican women on church and mission
Brokering the Good Friday Agreement: the untold story
Christ in all things: William Temple and his writings
Firmly I believe: an Oxford Movement reader
A heart strangely warmed: John and Charles Wesley and their writings
John Henry Newman and the path to sainthood,
Middle English devotional compilations: composi
A point of balance: the weight and measure of Anglicanism
The wills of our ancestors: a guide to probate records for family and local historians
Please note that since October 2019 Lambeth Palace Library is closed on Fridays. This is to give the staff time to prepare the collections for the move to the new library building. Opening hours are now 10am to 5pm on Tuesday and Wednesday, and 10am to 7.30 pm on Thursday. Additionally, 30th April 2020 will be the last day that the Lambeth Palace Library reading room will be open and also the last day that the Church of England Record Centre reading room will be open before the opening of the new building in early 2021. There might also be a delay in answering some types of enquiries.
ABTAPL Bulletin
The Church of England Newspaper
The name of Henry Bradshawe, and the family seat in Marple, Cheshire, in the seventeenth century, are familiar to bibliographers and to the book trade. According to the Oxford Dictionary of National Biography, John Bradshawe the regicide, being childless, bequeathed ‘all my Law Bookes,’ along with books ‘on divinity, history and other books’ to his nephew Henry, who maintained the family library until his death in 1698. This traditional account is an extreme simplification of the true story, which must start with the realization that books from the Bradshawe family library carry the ownership signatures of at least four Henry Bradshawes. Books from the library are scattered across the English-speaking world.
One of the most striking aspects of medieval manuscripts is their ravishing colours. Scientific advances mean that it is now possible, using non-invasive techniques, to identify the pigments that were used to produce the illuminations in question. This lecture will report the findings from recent investigations of illuminations in Lambeth Palace Library, explaining the processes that were used, summarising the pigments that were identified, and contextualising them within broader patterns of medieval and renaissance painting.
Fiona and Maria organising our conservation papers for the new studio
The vast majority of the papers from Archbishop Robert Runcie’s time in office (1980-1991) have now been catalogued and made publicly available. Significant progress is also being made with the appraisal and cataloguing of the papers of Archbishop George Carey. A range of other material has also been catalogued, such as small manuscript accessions relating to the Church Lads Brigade, Bishop Hensley Henson and the author Kathleen Bliss.
100 churches, 100 years,
Converting Britannia: evangelicals and British public life, 1770-1840
Eternal light: the sacred stained-glass windows of Louis Comfort Tiffany
Tim Harris and John Marshall (Woodbridge: The Boydell Press, 2019). More information available 
A rite on the edge: baptism and christening in the Church of England
Thomas Fuller: discovering England’s religious past
Who is my neighbour?: the global and personal challenge
MS 683 f.2r
More information and reviews available 
Bishop Richard Harries
guests
English Bibles on trial: Bible burning and the desecration of Bibles, 1640-1800
Designing sacred spaces
The rhetoric of Pope Francis: critical mercy and conversion for the twenty-first century
The Library is delighted that Mrs Clare Brown, Archivist, was awarded The Lanfranc Award for Education and Scholarship by Archbishop Welby at the 
A Monument of Fame 